How to Choose the Right Attorney for Your Case

Choosing the right attorney isn’t just important—it’s personal. Legal issues are stressful, emotional, and often high-stakes. Whether you’re facing criminal charges, going through a divorce, or dealing with a serious injury, you need a lawyer who gets it—and gets results. But with so many options, how do you find the one that’s right for you?

This guide walks you through the key things to consider so you can make an informed—and confident—decision.

Know What Kind of Lawyer You Need

Law is a wide field. Start by figuring out the kind of help you need. This helps narrow down attorneys who focus on your type of case:

• Criminal Law – DUI, assault, theft, drug charges
• Family Law – divorce, custody, child support, adoption
• Estate Planning – wills, probates, trusts, and elder care planning

Choosing a lawyer who focuses on the right area increases your chances of getting the best possible outcome.

Find Relevant Experience

Not all experience is equal. You want someone who’s handled cases like yours before—and won. Ask questions such as:

• How long have you worked in this field?
• Have you handled cases like mine before?
• What were the results?
• Do you work in the courts where my case will be heard?

Familiarity with local judges, court rules, and legal customs can make a real difference.

Check Reviews and Ask Around

Online reviews can reveal a lot. Look beyond the glowing testimonials on the lawyer’s website. Check third-party review platforms like:

• Google Reviews
• Avvo
• Martindale-Hubbell 

You can also ask friends, family, or other professionals for referrals. A good reputation in the community often means consistent results and satisfied clients.

Set Up a Consultation

A consultation is more than just a meet and greet. It’s your opportunity to assess whether the attorney is a good fit. Pay attention to:

• How well they listen
• How clearly they explain legal terms
• Whether they’ve handled similar cases 

You should walk away feeling heard and respected—not rushed, judged, or confused.

Understand the Fees

Attorney fees can vary widely. Don’t be afraid to ask for a full explanation. Common structures

• Flat Fee – A set amount for defined services. Common in straightforward matters like will drafting or other Wills and Estates services.
• Hourly Rate – Charged by the hour, often used in family law, criminal defense, or contested estate cases.
• Contingency Fee – Less common for Wills and Estates matters, but used in specific case types. You only pay if a favorable result is achieved.

Also ask about retainer fees, filing fees, and other potential costs. A good attorney is always transparent about money.

Make Sure They’re Available

Responsiveness is key. Ask:

• How quickly will you return calls or texts?
• How often will I receive updates?

Some attorneys are overloaded and slow to respond. That won’t help you in a time of stress. Find someone who values your time and treats your case with urgency.

Match Their Style to Your Case

Every lawyer has a different style. Some are aggressive litigators; others are calm negotiators. Think about your situation:

• A high-conflict divorce might need a bold, no-nonsense approach.
• A sensitive custody dispute may benefit from diplomacy and empathy.
• A criminal charge may require someone who’s strategic under pressure.

Choose someone whose style aligns with your needs and personality.

Check Credentials

This might seem obvious, but it’s often overlooked. Make sure your attorney is:

• Licensed to practice in your state
• In good standing with the state bar
• Free of any serious disciplinary actions

You can confirm these details on your state bar’s website. It’s a quick step that gives you peace of mind.

Don’t Choose Based on Price Alone

It’s tempting to choose the cheapest option, but cheaper doesn’t always mean better. An attorney who charges more may offer:

• More experience
• Greater availability
• Stronger courtroom presence

Legal representation is an investment. Don’t sacrifice quality to save a few bucks—especially when the outcome can impact your life for years to come.

Trust Your Gut

At the end of the day, trust your instincts. Do you feel comfortable opening up to this person? Do they respect your time and concerns? If something feels off, don’t ignore it.

You need to feel confident that your lawyer is on your side—for the long haul.

Choose a Lawyer Who Truly Understands

Navigating the complexities of legal issues requires more than knowledge—it requires someone who listens, cares, and fights for you. At The Law Office of Dustin N. Thomas, PLLC, we bring a fighter’s heart and real-world experience to every case.

Whether it’s criminal defense, family law, Wills and Estates, or estate planning, you’ll get honest answers and relentless advocacy. Our founding attorney, Dustin N. Thomas, doesn’t just talk like a regular person—he is one. With roots in Mississippi and experience in law enforcement and the courtroom, he brings practical insight and empathy to every case. Book your consultation today and talk to an attorney who understands what’s at stake.